[cap-talk] Horton at HotSec '07: How broadly object/capability?

[Stiegler, Marc D]

> > Since some of the referees were confused about some points, 
> and we're 
> > not getting more space, I think we should remove the implementation 
> > details.
> 
> I STRONGLY DISAGREE.
> 
> The people going to this workshop have limited time. They 
> will review the paper before the talk. They will scrutinize 
> the code. If they have to go to an outside source you have lost.

While I wouldn't put it in all caps, I agree with jonathan that the
implementation details should remain. The code is exquisitely laid out
in this paper. Some of the readers, like some of the reviewers, will be
put off by it. But others will find it a profound and rewarding
experience. Better to knock the socks off half the audience than to get
a ho-hum from the entire audience.

--marcs