[cap-talk] Petnames versus E-order with ocaps

David Wagner daw at cs.berkeley.edu
Wed Jan 28 19:02:27 EST 2009


Charles Landau  wrote:
>Karp, Alan H wrote:
>> If Bob has a reference to Carol that he calls foo, a
>> reference to Carol that Bob receives from Alice will also be denoted
>> foo.
>
> Those two references have different properties, so they are different 
> references, in other words references to different objects. So they 
> should have different petnames.

That sounds on the surface like it may have lousy usability properties.
Or perhaps what I mean to say is this.  Petnames exist for the purpose of
helping humans to use the system safely, so any consideration of whether
these two differences should have the same petname or not ought to take
into account human factors.


More information about the cap-talk mailing list